The comments table has been repopulated! I’m currently working on restoring their hierarchy. For ease, I’m working backwards, from the newest to the oldest posts. Please bear with any site instability/sluggishness you might encounter. Cheers! ☺

Monogatari Second Season Episode 17: Shinobu Time, Part One

しのぶタイム 其ノ壹, Japan, 26 October 2013, Raymond Santos Estrella

After watching Sengoku turn into a completely out of control snake-aberration that apparently wiped out everyone in this show, this week’s episode was a pleasant reminder that SHAFT really knows how to reel us back in after traumatizing us. And I while I can’t speak for everyone watching, I know that I’ll gladly take any opportunity for more Shinobu-time. So as I slowly recover from all the amazing shots of her that we were graced with this week, let me try to form complete sentences as I finish this post from a stuffy airplane with people looking at me funny for watching anime.

Warning! The following summary contains spoilers.


First off, I thought that this week’s episode was absolutely outstanding. If I were to compare everything else we’ve seen thus far, I’d have to say that SHAFT really outdid themselves this week. Sure that previous statement might be a little biased since all of my favorite characters got a ton of screen time and the arc just happens to be Shinobu’s, but I doubt you’ll find a soul out there who wouldn’t want a little more of everything that we got. From the brilliant and crisp quality in every single shot to some of the best jokes Monogatari has ever used, this week’s episode was a welcome reminder of just how amazing this show can be. Because, I mean come on, when was the last time you saw Araragi actually make out with two girls?


But even if you don’t like any of the main characters or didn’t find jokes about twin-tails falling off funny, the other great part of this week’s episode had to be the villain. Literally described as darkness that’s given form by those who acknowledge its existence with the power to purge the entire city into darkness, it normally would sound stupidly overpowered but in this case it’s awesomely perfect for Shinbou’s arc. Because with the way I see it, it sounds like this thing is deeply intertwined with Shinobu’s past which means there’s either gonna be a lot of cool fighting scenes or a lot of emotionally moving scenes. Both of which make me that much more excited for next week’s episode!

Quick note: this is not a double post! Last week’s episode was a quick recap of the events that occurred in Nisemonogatari. But in terms of keeping things numbered correctly, I include both episode numbers since that’s the official count provided by SHAFT.

Share This Review

Comments (53)

  • Red HeartGold ZX

    Red HeartGold ZX

    28 October 2013 at 01:49 |

    Just flashbacks? I was expecting events AFTER Sengoku’s ‘yandere’ outrage in the Episode after what seems to be the ‘BAD-END final episode’ but… Oh, well. Gotta learn not to expect in Monogatari Series. :3


  • Da5id


    28 October 2013 at 02:03 |

    >”SHAFT really knows how to reel us back in”

    >numerous shots of half naked Araragi kissing and touching lolis

    Raymond, I’m from To Catch A Predator. We’ll be taking you in now.


  • Sol


    28 October 2013 at 02:05 |

    Araragi the Italian.


  • thedarktower


    28 October 2013 at 02:27 |

    that episode was…wow. my head’s still spinning around because of watching it. in short—mindfuck.

    timeline of course has become a bit messy. well till now it was somehow OK.
    onimonogatari (or shinobu arc) is taking place after Kabukimonogatari (hachkuji arc), while otorimonogatari (Nadeko arc) is after that.
    but that’s not all actually it happens at the same time with Nekomonogatari: Shiro

    familiar with “kizumonogatari”? the second title of monogatari LN, and the first one in chronological order of the series. it tells the tale when Araragi met up with shinobu (and became a vampire). although it seems unimportant, it has become essential as we could notice from the epilogue of the ep. moreover, along the series (nisemono, nekomono) there are “references” to events in Kizu. so it’s become important IMO. too bad shaft hasn’t made the movie/special/whatever it is yet.

    anyway, monogatari as always, first ep of an arc is full of riddles and hints we must pay attention. that’s why I said Kizu is important (for the record, I did read Kizu but I haven’t read onimonogatari, yet I can feel it’s important).
    we know the darkness is related to sniobu’s first subordinate. maybe it’s him. we also know from kizu that he is probably shinbu’s lover.

    it’ll be quite interesting

    Araragi got 2 kisses this episode…Nadeko?Hitgai is gonna kill him.


  • Ananas


    28 October 2013 at 02:39 |



  • Stiltzkin


    28 October 2013 at 02:57 |

    Ononoki stole the show this week for me. Love how she always keeps a straight face (and being voiced by the lovely Hayami Saori no less).


  • Faint Smile

    Faint Smile

    28 October 2013 at 03:12 |

    My most anticipated arc!…


  • Espada


    28 October 2013 at 03:18 |

    best girl winning


  • Euzio


    28 October 2013 at 03:29 |

    Tsundere vampire? XD

    It kinda seems to me that Shinobu actually enjoyed that kiss before she starting complaining :P


  • echykr


    28 October 2013 at 03:38 |

    Let’s see, this episode, Araragi has put his hands all over one sleeping lolis while consecutively kissing two lolis.

    Still, technically speaking, one is 21 years old (Mayoi), one is 600 years old (Shinobu) and another one is undead for quite some time (Ononoki), making them all older by Araragi by default, does that make Araragi a True Lolicon or just simply an Undead Lolicon? XD

    So far, the only truly underaged girls he’s ever “roughed up” were his sisters, which he claims he doesn’t feel a thing for (bar the Toothbrush Incident with Karen). He almost nearly went criminal with Nadeko but was intervened by Shinobu’s Anti-Lolicon Vampire Punch.


  • cryarc


    28 October 2013 at 03:39 |

    It needs another season to elaborate those events, 1-2 slot eps left from this season won’t enough to do the job <_<


  • echykr


    28 October 2013 at 03:40 |

    Ononoki-chan finally managed to somewhat avenge getting her ass whooped by Shinobu by kissing Shinobu’s man.

    And the way she swooned over Araragi’s muscles would make Matsuoka Gou very proud. :D


  • Cybersteel


    28 October 2013 at 04:17 |

    And Araragi was half-naked for no apparent reason… Atleast we get a double loli this arc…


  • Ray


    28 October 2013 at 04:41 |

    actually they explained it in the LN: the speed they used when escaping the darkness was to fast that it teared off his clothes


  • Crook


    28 October 2013 at 05:40 |

    When Ononoki jumped? Then why are her clothes fine?


  • echykr


    28 October 2013 at 06:19 |

    And it still doesn’t explain how Araragi managed to keep his boxers on. :)


  • Euzio


    28 October 2013 at 07:41 |

    The laws of fiction kinda makes it such that no matter what happens, your undergarments will remain intact even if the rest of your clothes get blown off (though in certain cases, this law is broken. Mainly involving female characters….)


  • Ryan Ashlight

    Ryan Ashlight

    28 October 2013 at 08:02 |

    DAT KISS… !!!

    But, oh sweet merciful goddess, my Senjougahara yandere senses are tingling like crazy! Run, Araragi, run!!

    Anyways, that aside, an all-around awesome ep to start off my favorite character’s arc, indeed. However will our heroes manage against a foe that swallowed up Shinobu in her prime? No worries, for there’s no foe that the power of love can’t overcome!

    …Except, mayhaps a crazy ass snake-haired girl who turned herself into a god, right? O__O


  • x


    28 October 2013 at 08:21 |

    Well this episode certainly leave enough hints as to why Koyomi was out of the picture for much of Nekemonogatari Shiro :p.


  • Bear


    28 October 2013 at 08:38 |

    Enjoyed? She practically melted in his arms. He would be lucky if Senjougahara just killed him if she finds out about this.


  • Bear


    28 October 2013 at 08:40 |

    Given the way he looked when he showed up, this is going to be one hell of a ride.


  • ElZenom


    28 October 2013 at 08:58 |



  • LaughingMan


    28 October 2013 at 09:19 |



  • Nitro


    28 October 2013 at 09:22 |

    nah. it was perfect and you’re just in denial.


  • Rooserloom


    28 October 2013 at 09:35 |

    *drowns in pool of nose blood


  • K2013


    28 October 2013 at 09:44 |

    Araragi should be in jail xD


  • Senjougahara Hitagi

    Senjougahara Hitagi

    28 October 2013 at 09:58 |

    Well son, what you need to learn is something else.

    You should have at least known the fact that Koimonogatari will be included in this season, right?

    This is the timeline for this season: First, Kabukimonogatari (time leap). Second, Onimonogatari (this arc) together with Nekomonogatari White, which happened at the same time. The third one is Otorimonogatari, and Koimonogatari happens last, which will be through Kaiki’s/Hitagi’s point of view, and which will also be a followup to Nadeko’s arc.


  • 7godeohs


    28 October 2013 at 10:52 |

    Question: I’m pretty sure Araragi is not immortal, but does have a much longer lifespan. Do we know how long and if he will age at a normal pace. Just wondering what that means for Hitagi and the reasonable possibility (or impossibility) of children given their future fate.

    Also, if we looked to the far future (one where Hitagi is no more :( ) and one were to ship Araragi and Shinobu, how weird would that be? Assuming that Shinobu changes her appearance to a non-loli age, you’d still have the possibility of your girlfriend being able to live in your shadow. I think some people in relationships now might feel that way. Still, to have those two together it might be worth it.


  • Saphirio


    28 October 2013 at 11:07 |

    His clothes…
    Jacket as a blanket and jeans as a pillow.


  • RyanAshlight


    28 October 2013 at 12:03 |

    Meh, I don’t think it’d be all that weird at all, honestly; though, not to be a stickler or anything (just because I honestly think it’s important to point out), I’d hesitate to call Shinobu Araragi’s girlfriend or anything quite so mundane.

    As Shinobu herself pointed out this very episode, she’s Araragi’s “lifelong partner,” putting her in a class all her own.

    These two have (based on what snippets I’ve seen from Kizumonogatari) tried to kill each other, understand each other on a level that should make we mere mortals tinge with jealously, and have even pledged to die together.

    Perhaps it sounds a bit strange, but I don’t really see Shinobu and Araragi as being two distinctly individual people anymore, and so it’s hard for me to view anything that the two of them do together as ‘weird.’


  • thedarktower


    28 October 2013 at 12:04 |

    Araragi isn’t immortal.
    neither he is vampire, nor he is completely human. you can say he is half-vampire, though according to the LN this term is wrong. unlike Episode (the character) which is definitely half-vampire, Araragi is a vampire-like pseudo-human, that’s why he has some features of vampire—regeneration and super-power (not like when he was vampire but compare to human it’s a huge difference) and more.

    anyway…in nisemono, he was taking a bath with shinbou (so pervert!) and shinobu said it’s possible he’ll live couple hundreds years.
    we don’t for sure whether shinobu is right or just tease him in order to be killed by him so he’ll turn human.

    so I don’t know what the future holds for him in that matter you pointed out.

    shinobu appearance won’t turn non-loli unless she regain her vampire-powers, which means a change in Araragi’s status as well. so it’s complicated enough :S


  • livid


    28 October 2013 at 12:19 |

    Why do I have a feeling Ougi has something to do with this…oh, right, they showed her at the start of the episode. And whenever I see Ougi, I get the “Uh oh, shit’s gonna hit the fan” feeling. I say she’s the hidden Big Bad (


  • inanis


    28 October 2013 at 13:09 |

    wow that kiss… Shinobu melted right away (and shes SOOOOO CUTE)

    Interesting episode… lol Araragi always getting interrupted when trying to “play” with the lolis

    One was to wonder tho… what Hitagi’s reaction would be (then again… i personally think Shinobu ranks higher in the “relationship scale” … they are closer than married people o.o … didnt know they were “mind-linked” …

    lol @ Ononoki-cha’s “revenge” (tho she does seem a little “too fixated” in Araragi’s muscles… lol)

    Sooo so far he’s kissed 2 people of his “Harem” (tho calling it an harem is wrong)

    PS: and Shinobu’s CANT go to her ORIGINAL shape w/o killing Araragi… but she can go to a teen-like form… as she did in Kizu, she just has to drink more than what she normaly does (meaning Araragi goes deeper into “vamp territory”


  • livid


    28 October 2013 at 14:06 |

    By the way, anyone knows what those chemical bindings were? At first glans, it looks like an alcoholic binding. They trying to tell us Araragi was drunk? :p


  • Cenosored


    28 October 2013 at 14:46 |

    Loved this episode, and I find it interesting that Hachikuju and Shinobu are both deeply entwined in each others arcs…For some reason I never would have expected that, but it works out really well


  • SmithCB


    28 October 2013 at 15:49 |

    I’m sorry, but given this episode, earlier discussions about Hnnnnnngh! and whales, it just gave me a whole new meaning to “Free Willy”…!!!!!!!!!! If this was already mentioned, Gomen!


  • livid


    28 October 2013 at 16:12 |

    Not to mention the whole kissing event happened while she was deliberately stepping on Araragi’s shadow. Kinda like saying “In your face” :p


  • PrimeHector


    28 October 2013 at 17:41 |

    What if there’s an apparition hiding under her skirt?


  • Eri


    28 October 2013 at 18:26 |

    THANK YOU! Someone actually noticed and mentioned it.


  • sealouse


    28 October 2013 at 19:11 |

    Speaking of Ougi and that whole intro. How can shots of someone running be so interesting? I think I’m becoming a little obsessed with her. Also that soundtrack. OMG! Hello?


  • Raine


    28 October 2013 at 19:15 |

    “Why don’t you take a seat over there, Raymond?”


  • Raymond Santos Estrella

    Raymond Santos Estrella

    28 October 2013 at 21:12 |

    Koyomi Araragi—Ace Detective


  • Geoff


    28 October 2013 at 21:57 |

    Never leave a stone unturned!


  • thedarktower


    29 October 2013 at 05:44 |

    he probably thought the “darkness” in under her skirt :P
    or most likely the whitness as in Hanekawa case XD


  • nexushero


    29 October 2013 at 07:00 |

    I have the weirdest boner……


  • Yuriko


    29 October 2013 at 07:17 |

    I heard that Shinobu won’t have her own opening because Sakamoto Maaya’s contract prevents her from doing character songs…

    I’m really disappointed.


  • livid


    29 October 2013 at 08:28 |

    Really??? Aaah, and I was really looking forward to it…


  • drzero7


    29 October 2013 at 09:54 |

    Someone needs to put a Pedobear seal of approval on this episode. And man, at this rate, Araragi will go to jail. He ignored his GF and molested 3 lolis in one episode.


  • inanis


    29 October 2013 at 15:32 |

    well… technically only 2 since Ononoki-chan molested HIM…
    … actually only 2 lolis since Mayoi-chin would be older than him if she were alive…
    … mm really none… since Shinobu-sama is like 600 years old.


  • inanis


    29 October 2013 at 15:33 |

    *actually only 1…

    Gee typos


  • Dangerism


    29 October 2013 at 19:17 |

    So the Mayoi arc has lots of Shinobu, while the Shinobu arc has lots of Mayoi? Got it.


  • Izan


    30 October 2013 at 23:27 |

    actually its none, mayoi is technically 20+ lolz


  • CCrandom


    13 February 2014 at 02:45 |

    I know i’m a bit late but, If only that darkness had a Eyeball and said “Damn all you lolicons!” That would have made my day and explain why it was chasing Araragi.


Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest. Optional login below.